Finding the right running shoe can get tricky. We all want to go for the most stylish pair with attractive colors and designs, but many times these nice-looking kicks end up destroying our feet. As a runner and physical therapist I have learned along the way that the single most important gear to be picky about for running (or really any activity that has you standing or walking for long periods of time) are shoes. If you are an occasional runner who gets in a few miles every week just to stay active, one pair at a time is sufficient. But runners training for a distance event, especially those who incorporate different types of runs require a couple of pairs to rotate through. And it involves more than just “cushioned” or “light” when shopping around.
Know Your Foot Type
The first thing every runner should do when selecting shoes is figure out their foot type. Are you a pronator? Do you excessively supinate when you land? Do you have high arches? What does this all mean anyway?!
Pronator: This is when you land on the inner part of your foot when running. Most of the time runners initially land on the outer border of the foot, but quickly roll inward excessively. Those with low arches usually fall in this category.
Supinator: This is when you land on the outer border of the foot and remain with the majority of the pressure on this area throughout the midstance and even into the push-off phase of running. Those with high arches will fall into this category.
There are several running shoe stores that offer a gait analysis that can give you an idea of your foot type, but the best analysis would be by a podiatrist or sports medicine professional that specializes in gait and has access to the technology. A great way to analyze your foot type that can be done at home is checking the wear on your current or an old pair of running shoes. If you notice the wearing is excessive on the outer border, you can assume you are a supinator and you underpronate when you land. A pronator would have excessive wear on the inner border. If your shoes have even wear, you most likely have a neutral arch and pronate a normal amount.
Next Step: Shoe Type
Cushioned: Supinators should opt for cushioned shoes (at least for the majority of their runs). They provide optimal comfort (cushioning) with the least amount of firmness in order to promote a bit more pronation when landing. Cushioned shoes are made to be more flexible, but not all flexible shoes are cushioned! Some cushioned shoe examples are New Balance Fresh Foam, Brooks Adrenaline, and Saucony Omni.
Motion Control: This shoe type is made with more rigid materials in order to control the foot from rolling inward too much. Overpronators or runners with flat feet will benefit from motion control shoes since they include a more dense midsole, which helps raise the arch of the foot. Saucony Kinvara, New Balance 1540, and Brooks Ravena are all great shoes for low arches.
Stability: If you are a neutral runner, then stability shoes are your go-to. Most will have a firm rear and flexible forefoot with a moderate amount of cushioning. Some examples are the Saucony Guide Iso 2 (one of my favorites!), Adidas Ultraboost, and Nike Air Zoom Pegasus.
Shoe Rotation
If you are an everyday runner, alternating between faster paced running, track sessions, and easy runs, it is best to rotate between two or three pairs. Opting for lightweight, flexible shoes are best for speed sessions. Shoes made for the track or even most “racing” shoes such as the Nike Vaporfly 4%, generally do not have much cushioning. As long as you limit the use of this type of shoe to short track repeats and racing, your feet won’t be affected too much. For the majority of your weekly runs (which should be at a conversational/easy pace), it is ideal to use the shoes that are best for your foot type as explained above.
Everyone has different feet and running form varies greatly, so what works for one person may not work for another. Just because you see a “fast” runner using a pair of the brand new Nikes does not mean you should go out and spend the money to use the same style. Well, first of all, a shoe does not necessarily make you faster. If you find you run faster in a given pair of shoes it is your better foot mechanics that are making you faster, not the actual shoe. The best advice if you are having any foot, knee, hip, or back pain during or after running, is to definitely evaluate your running mechanics and foot type. Switching to the right shoe for you can be a simple fix to a nagging problem.